smartgrrrl's guide to stuff

smartgrrrl's guide to stuff header image 2

Lost – LA X (Beginning of the End)

February 3rd, 2010 · 18 Comments · lost, reviews, television

I’ve already seen the first episode of Season 6. If you haven’t, don’t read this unless you want to know what happens. Hit N in your Google Reader.

OK. I firmly believe two things: 1) There’s no way Lindelof and Cuse are going to be able to provide all the answers to everything from the first 5 seasons; and 2) I don’t want them to. I don’t want everything tied up in a neat little package. I want there to be loose ends, unresolved issues. I want them to finish telling their story, not the story I think they’re telling, or the story I want to tell. I do have questions (lots of them, as you’ll see), and points I would like to see addressed during the course of this season, but I don’t necessarily think that their exclusion will be disappointing. (Depends on what IS there. Like, for example, if they choose to not return to the Adam and Eve in the cave, fine, as long as they don’t devote another episode to something as trivial as Jack’s tattoos.)

1. So! It looks like they’re going with parallel worlds this season. Or rather, many-worlds. From Wikipedia: “Proponents argue that many-worlds reconciles how we can perceive non-deterministic events, such as the random decay of a radioactive atom, with the deterministic equations of quantum physics. Prior to many-worlds, reality had been viewed as a single ‘world-line.’ Many-worlds, rather, views reality as a many-branched tree where every possible quantum outcome is realized.”

The simpler, less-physicsy version of this goes like this, I think (I could be getting this all wrong): This morning I had the choice between making coffee or not making coffee. I chose to make coffee, but in that moment I created an alternate world in which I do not make coffee. From there, I could choose whether to not drink coffee at all or go out and buy already made coffee from somewhere in my neighborhood. I suppose there’s even an alternate world in which I get on a bus or a subway and go to Cafe Grumpy, or something.

In other words, Sliding Doors.

2. Last season Daniel explained that he’d been so focused on the constants that he hadn’t considered the variables, which were people, who act out of their own free will. If they think they can’t change the past, then the past will not change. Enter Juliet, who exercises free will and detonates the bomb, causing at least two individual timelines to happen: the one where the plane doesn’t crash, the Reset Button World (RBW), and the one where they’re all still on the island.

3. Except they’re no longer in 1977. They’ve caught up to 2007. (Even with Jacob appearing to Hurley just after he died, this took me a while to figure out.)

4. According to Miles, Juliet’s last words to Sawyer were going to be “It worked.” Just before she dies, she says something about getting a cup of coffee. This reminded me of the mind-skipping that Charlotte does when the island jumps around in time/space, and it’s how Juliet knows that what she did helped, sort of. So while I thought that it was sort of pointless to bring her back just to watch her die again, that scene did have some value beyond allowing Sawyer to give her a proper, heartwrenching goodbye.

5. And of course, it didn’t work, not exactly, because the RBW isn’t what it was in the original 2004 timeline. Shannon’s not on the plane, but Desmond is (even though he disappears at some point) and Charlie’s not looking for a fix, he’s trying to kill himself (I think). And Hurley doesn’t feel cursed. I was so sure, based on all these tiny differences, that Locke — after talking about all the stuff he did on the walkabout — wouldn’t be in his wheelchair. Oh, and Christian’s coffin wasn’t on the plane at all. INTERESTING. (Maybe.)

6. All the little encounters that people had in the RBW — Jack running into Kate outside the airplane bathroom, Boone and Locke talking to each other over Frogurt (Frogurt!), Jack and Locke commiserating over lost luggage — all that felt to me like a Richard Bach novel. I sort of liked it, but I was sort of rolling my eyes at the same time.

7. Jack seeming to recognize Desmond — was that an island deja vu, or the stadium run deja vu? Both? What was up with Jack’s neck bleeding?

8. Maybe Desmond was blipping in and out of time/space again? (Henry Ian Cusick would make a good Doctor.) Although he didn’t seem all distraught or confused.

9. In the meantime, in the RBW, the island is underwater. I don’t know what to make of that right now. (But nice cameo from the DHARMA shark.)

10. I did like the conversation between Locke and Jack near the end, when Locke tells Jack that Oceanic didn’t lose Christian, they just lost his body. And then when Jack asks Locke what happened to him and then said “Nothing’s irreversible” — it was like Mr. Fixit was on the scene again, but also it a sentiment that pretty much sums up everything about the island, right?

11. I think everyone pretty much suspected that Locke was the Man in Black, who was also possibly the Smoke Monster, but we got confirmation of that last night. But . . . is he a shapeshifter? Form of: smoke?

12. More intriguey-ness: OK, first — it’s not like the Smoke Monster/Man in Black/Fuck it I’m just going to start referring to this entity as Nemesis was actually inhabiting Locke’s body; more like he was assuming its form. If he’s not in Locke’s body, how did he access Locke’s mind? How did he know that Locke’s last thought was “I don’t understand”? And then, all Nemesis wants to do is go home? So, he’s not an island native? But he’s been on the island at least as long as Jacob has, and was on the island in 1867 or whenever it was that the Black Rock crashed. (Is Jacob also not an island native?)

13. Oh, speaking of the Black Rock! Nemesis tells Richard “nice to see you out of these chains.” Was Richard ON that ship? As a SLAVE? Dude.

14. And we finally saw the inside of the temple. Not gonna lie to you, one of the thoughts that ran through my head was “Are they all in ninja training?” But really, the temple was cool. We get to see Cindy — and it’s a Cindy who seems much more . . . powerful, I think, is the word. Not like “in charge” powerful, but . . . she just seems different.

15. The guy with the Lennon glasses reminded me a little of Dennis Hopper in Apocalypse Now. No significance to that, just wanted to mention it.

16. The temple has a pool of healing water (that makes sense, given how Rose’s cancer disappeared and Locke could walk), even though it wasn’t running clear as it should be, and didn’t heal the cut on the leader’s hand. Yet it somehow still saved Sayid (eventually). So this is what happened to Ben as a child as well, I take it. Does this mean that Sayid is now the de facto leader of the Others? Maybe that’s too simple. But it’s not Ben anymore, and it’s certainly not Locke, so . . . hmm.

17. It’s going to be rough, waiting a week between episodes.

18. What did I miss?

No related posts.

Tags: ···

  • rosemartelli

    Was there any indication given in as to *why* detonating the H-bomb would somehow catapult those on-island to 2007? I mean, Lapidus/Sun/etc. didn't experience it/feel it, right? Is that time-jump to present day one of those things we just go with? Does fucking with things as much as H-bomb detonating hit a reset button that puts all those within the scope of the bomb back to “square one,” which would be “present day?”

    I guess the Jacob/Hurley encounter could be seen as the proof that those who'd been, in season 5, on the 2007 island are now of the same time frame as the 1977 islanders, but I don't know if I fully buy that, because if anyone could skip about at will, it's Jacob.

    For a few minutes last night I got pretty obsessed with whether or not Locke *had* been allowed on that walkabout. Was that his bit of slightly-different reality vis-a-vis season 1? What that his Shannon-deciding-not-to-come, his one-vodka-bottle-instead-of-two?

    Except if it was, he would not have been on that particular flight, which was booked for him after being forbidden from the walkabout. Meaning, if he had gone of the walkabout, he would have been *on* it at the time Flight 815 took off, right?

  • http://twitter.com/afm_ anne

    I wondering if Sayid is really still Sayid – if Nemesis could take impersonate/take over/inhabit John somehow, I'm wondering if Sayid is now, somehow, going to become Jacob?

  • http://www.crankymonkeybutt.com/ carolyn

    Cindy? Who is Cindy? That must be something I missed!

  • Jackie

    I'm thinking now that Sayid is not….Sayid.

  • Jackie

    and I posted that before I saw Anne's comment. Hmm. Could be.

    Cindy was the flight attendant on 815.

  • http://smartgrrrl.tumblr.com Michelle

    Gah — I had this long comment in reply to everything here and something went wrong. Shorthanding it now:

    Rose — I think the main point is that Jack, Kate, Jin, etc. weren't supposed to be in 1977, and the H-bomb detonating sent them back, somehow, to their own time.

    Unless the bomb never went off? The white light was the same electromagnetic-based white light from when the hatch first imploded?

    Anne — I had the same thought about Sayid reincarnating as Jacob, but I'm not sure. I'm still running with the idea that what happened with Sayid in the temple is what happened to Ben in 1977 (and nice circling back there, since Sayid is why Ben had to go to the temple in the first place). Richard had said that Ben would be changed forever, and that he wouldn't remember anything. I don't know if Sayid is still essentially Sayid, but I think it's safe to say that he's not the same Sayid we've known for the last 5 seasons.

    I wonder if it matters that the water wasn't clear — and why wasn't it? (Because Jacob was killed?)

  • flabtastic

    Regarding your #7 Jack recognized Desmond b/c he had seen him one time prior – back in LA running around that track and night – that was the first time we saw Desmond in the show too – so Jack didn't have Deja-Vu – he just struggled to remember where he had seen him before… Also, Desmond was on the plane b/c in the new parallel reality, he had successfully sailed to Australia, never got trapped on the island pushing the button, and so he was flying back home to LA – presumably to be reunited with Penny, and he happened to be on the same flight. I don't think he disappeared, maybe just returned to his real seat. I think we'll see him again in another episode, brutha…

  • http://smartgrrrl.tumblr.com Michelle

    Right, it's not technically “deja vu” that Jack is going through when he
    sees Desmond — but I think maybe there's more going on than him struggling
    to remember why Des looked so familiar. In the original flashbacks, Jack
    seems relatively unshaken by the turbulence. In Reset Button World, he's got
    this “something is seriously wrong” look and he's gripping the chair. (It's
    Rose, in the S1 flashback, that's so upset by the turbulence, when now it's
    Rose that tells Jack he can relax — she's soothing him.) (Also, granted,
    Jack looks the way I always look during turbulence.)

    And the race around the world way before 2004, so presumably Desmond would
    have already gotten back to Penny. It could be total coincidence that he's
    on that plane, and you're right, it could be just that he's gone back to his
    other seat. But it's Desmond. There's gotta be more there than meets the
    eye.

    And what about this: Desmond likes boats. Instead of simply flying from
    Heathrow to LAX to get to Mrs. Hawking, he and Penny sail there. Assuming
    that all else is the same with Desmond — that he did, in fact, go on the
    race around the world, that he is with Penny (maybe he never met Libby and
    got the boat in this world, and never went on the race in the first place)
    – why would he be on a flight, as opposed to just setting sail for LA?

    I am so happy this show is back.

  • flabtastic

    Wow, you just pushed MY reset button!

  • rosemartelli

    Was there any indication given in as to *why* detonating the H-bomb would somehow catapult those on-island to 2007? I mean, Lapidus/Sun/etc. didn't experience it/feel it, right? Is that time-jump to present day one of those things we just go with? Does fucking with things as much as H-bomb detonating hit a reset button that puts all those within the scope of the bomb back to “square one,” which would be “present day?”

    I guess the Jacob/Hurley encounter could be seen as the proof that those who'd been, in season 5, on the 2007 island are now of the same time frame as the 1977 islanders, but I don't know if I fully buy that, because if anyone could skip about at will, it's Jacob.

    For a few minutes last night I got pretty obsessed with whether or not Locke *had* been allowed on that walkabout. Was that his bit of slightly-different reality vis-a-vis season 1? What that his Shannon-deciding-not-to-come, his one-vodka-bottle-instead-of-two?

    Except if it was, he would not have been on that particular flight, which was booked for him after being forbidden from the walkabout. Meaning, if he had gone of the walkabout, he would have been *on* it at the time Flight 815 took off, right?

  • http://twitter.com/afm_ anne

    I wondering if Sayid is really still Sayid – if Nemesis could take impersonate/take over/inhabit John somehow, I'm wondering if Sayid is now, somehow, going to become Jacob?

  • http://www.crankymonkeybutt.com/ carolyn

    Cindy? Who is Cindy? That must be something I missed!

  • Jackie

    I'm thinking now that Sayid is not….Sayid.

  • Jackie

    and I posted that before I saw Anne's comment. Hmm. Could be.

    Cindy was the flight attendant on 815.

  • http://smartgrrrl.tumblr.com Michelle

    Gah — I had this long comment in reply to everything here and something went wrong. Shorthanding it now:

    Rose — I think the main point is that Jack, Kate, Jin, etc. weren't supposed to be in 1977, and the H-bomb detonating sent them back, somehow, to their own time.

    Unless the bomb never went off? The white light was the same electromagnetic-based white light from when the hatch first imploded?

    Anne — I had the same thought about Sayid reincarnating as Jacob, but I'm not sure. I'm still running with the idea that what happened with Sayid in the temple is what happened to Ben in 1977 (and nice circling back there, since Sayid is why Ben had to go to the temple in the first place). Richard had said that Ben would be changed forever, and that he wouldn't remember anything. I don't know if Sayid is still essentially Sayid, but I think it's safe to say that he's not the same Sayid we've known for the last 5 seasons.

    I wonder if it matters that the water wasn't clear — and why wasn't it? (Because Jacob was killed?)

  • flabtastic

    Regarding your #7 Jack recognized Desmond b/c he had seen him one time prior – back in LA running around that track and night – that was the first time we saw Desmond in the show too – so Jack didn't have Deja-Vu – he just struggled to remember where he had seen him before… Also, Desmond was on the plane b/c in the new parallel reality, he had successfully sailed to Australia, never got trapped on the island pushing the button, and so he was flying back home to LA – presumably to be reunited with Penny, and he happened to be on the same flight. I don't think he disappeared, maybe just returned to his real seat. I think we'll see him again in another episode, brutha…

  • http://smartgrrrl.tumblr.com Michelle

    Right, it's not technically “deja vu” that Jack is going through when he
    sees Desmond — but I think maybe there's more going on than him struggling
    to remember why Des looked so familiar. In the original flashbacks, Jack
    seems relatively unshaken by the turbulence. In Reset Button World, he's got
    this “something is seriously wrong” look and he's gripping the chair. (It's
    Rose, in the S1 flashback, that's so upset by the turbulence, when now it's
    Rose that tells Jack he can relax — she's soothing him.) (Also, granted,
    Jack looks the way I always look during turbulence.)

    And the race around the world way before 2004, so presumably Desmond would
    have already gotten back to Penny. It could be total coincidence that he's
    on that plane, and you're right, it could be just that he's gone back to his
    other seat. But it's Desmond. There's gotta be more there than meets the
    eye.

    And what about this: Desmond likes boats. Instead of simply flying from
    Heathrow to LAX to get to Mrs. Hawking, he and Penny sail there. Assuming
    that all else is the same with Desmond — that he did, in fact, go on the
    race around the world, that he is with Penny (maybe he never met Libby and
    got the boat in this world, and never went on the race in the first place)
    – why would he be on a flight, as opposed to just setting sail for LA?

    I am so happy this show is back.

  • flabtastic

    Wow, you just pushed MY reset button!